Whether you're manufacturing plastics, food, pharmaceuticals, paints, textiles, packaging, or consumer products, accurate color measurement is essential for maintaining product consistency and meeting customer expectations. Two of the most common instruments used for objective color measurement are colorimeters and spectrophotometers. While both instruments measure color objectively, a colorimeter measures colorimetric values directly, whereas a spectrophotometer measures the complete spectral fingerprint from which colorimetric values are calculated.
Understanding these differences will help you choose the right instrument for your application and avoid investing in technology that may not meet your long-term quality objectives.
Why Objective Color Measurement Matters
Human vision is remarkably sensitive to color differences, yet visual color evaluation is influenced by lighting conditions, observer perception, fatigue, and surrounding colors. Instrumental color measurement removes this subjectivity by providing repeatable, traceable, and standardized color data.
Both colorimeters and spectrophotometers can report color values such as CIELAB, but the way they obtain those values—and the information they retain—is very different.
What Is a Colorimeter?
According to the International Commission on Illumination (CIE), a colorimeter is:
"An instrument for measuring colorimetric quantities, such as the tristimulus values of a colour stimulus."
ASTM further distinguishes a tristimulus (filter) colorimeter from a spectrophotometer (spectrocolorimeter), emphasizing that spectrophotometers measure spectral data from which colorimetric values are calculated.
Rather than measuring the complete visible spectrum, a colorimeter measures light using three broad-band optical filters designed to approximate the CIE Standard Observer color matching functions (X̄, Ȳ, and Z̄).
The instrument directly measures the tristimulus values X, Y, and Z, which are then used to calculate color spaces such as:
- CIE L*, a*, b*
- CIE L*, C*, h°
- XYZ
- ΔE*
Unlike inexpensive consumer RGB sensors, industrial colorimeters are tristimulus instruments, not simple RGB devices. Their optical filters are carefully engineered to approximate human color perception as defined by the CIE.
How does a colorimeter work?
1. A stable light source illuminates the sample.
2. Reflected or transmitted light passes through three broad-band optical filters.
3. Each filter approximates one of the CIE Standard Observer response curves.
4. Three detectors measure the filtered light.
5. The instrument calculates the X, Y, and Z tristimulus values.
6. Color spaces such as CIELAB are calculated from these values.
7. The original spectral information is not retained, only the calculated colorimetric values.
Advantages of a Colorimeter
- Fast measurements
- Excellent repeatability for routine quality control
- Simple operation
- Lower acquisition and maintenance cost for many routine applications.
- Ideal for production environments requiring rapid pass/fail decisions
What are the limitations of a colorimeter?
A colorimeter measures only the final colorimetric values. Because it does not retain spectral information, it cannot fully support advanced analyses such as:
- Spectral comparisons
- Metamerism evaluation
- Color formulation
- Accurate illuminant simulation
- Many specialized color indices. Examples include:
- Yellowness Index
- Whiteness Index
- Color Strength
- APHA
- Gardner
- Opacity
- Haze
The following comparison summarizes the fundamental differences between tristimulus and spectral color measurement.
What Is a Spectrophotometer?
A spectrophotometer measures the spectral reflectance or spectral transmittance of a sample at many individual wavelengths across the visible spectrum.
Rather than measuring only three broad color responses, a spectrophotometer measures a continuous series of wavelengths—typically throughout the visible range of 400–700 nm.
Many spectrophotometers also extend beyond the visible spectrum into the ultraviolet (UV) and near infrared (NIR) for specialized analytical applications.
The result is a complete spectral fingerprint of the sample. Because the complete spectrum is measured and stored, new color calculations can often be performed later without remeasuring the sample.
How does a spectrophotometer work?
1. A stable light source illuminates the sample.
2. Reflected or transmitted light enters a monochromator (typically a diffraction grating).
3. Individual wavelengths are separated.
4. A detector array measures the light intensity at many narrow wavelength intervals.
5. The instrument produces a complete spectral reflectance or transmittance curve.
6. CIELAB, XYZ, ΔE, color indices, and other values are calculated from the measured spectrum.
Why is spectral data important?
A spectrophotometer measures and stores the sample's complete spectral fingerprint—far more information than the three tristimulus values measured by a colorimeter.
Because the complete spectrum is available, a single measurement can be used to calculate a wide range of color spaces, color indices, and advanced analytical metrics.
Color Spaces
- CIE L*, a*, b*
- CIE L*, C*, h°
- XYZ
- ΔE*
- Yellowness Index (YI)
- Whiteness Index (WI)
- APHA
- Gardner
- Tint
- Color Strength
- Metamerism evaluation
- Spectral comparison
- Color formulation
- Traceability and spectral archiving
Think of the measured spectrum as your sample's optical fingerprint. Every reported color value—including CIELAB, ΔE*, YI, WI, APHA, Gardner, and many others—is calculated from this spectral fingerprint.
Because the complete spectrum is preserved, the data can be reanalyzed in the future without remeasuring the sample, providing maximum flexibility, traceability, and confidence in your color measurements.
Spectrophotometer vs. Colorimeter
| Feature | Colorimeter | Spectrophotometer |
| Measures visible wavelengths | Yes (400–700 nm using three broad-band filters) | Yes (400–700 nm using narrow wavelength measurements) |
| Retains spectral data | No | Yes |
| Calculates CIELAB | Yes | Yes |
| Calculates XYZ | Yes | Yes |
| Detects metamerism | Limited | Yes |
| Simulates different illuminants | Limited | Yes |
| Color formulation | No | Yes |
| Spectral fingerprint | No | Yes |
| Routine quality control | Excellent | Excellent |
| Advanced color analysis is required | Limited | Excellent |
Should I choose a colorimeter or a spectrophotometer?
Both technologies have important roles in industrial color measurement.
A colorimeter may be the right choice when:
- Routine pass/fail decisions are required
- Measurements are straightforward
- Speed and simplicity are priorities
- Spectral analysis is unnecessary
- Advanced color analysis and flexibility are required
- Products are evaluated under multiple lighting conditions
- Color formulation is performed
- Metamerism must be evaluated
- Regulatory traceability is important
- Color data must support research and development
- Future flexibility is desired
A colorimeter tells you what color a sample appears to be.
A spectrophotometer tells you why it appears that color.
Key Takeaway
A colorimeter measures colorimetric values directly using three broad-band optical filters that approximate human vision, making it an excellent choice for routine production color control.
A spectrophotometer measures the complete visible spectrum, creating a spectral fingerprint from which colorimetric values—and many additional analyses—can be calculated. For applications requiring maximum flexibility, traceability, and advanced color analysis, a spectrophotometer provides the most comprehensive solution.
Industry Standards
Color measurement terminology and methodology are defined by internationally recognized standards, including:
- CIE S 017 – International Lighting Vocabulary
- ASTM E284 – Terminology of Appearance
- ASTM E1347 – Tristimulus (Filter) Colorimetry
- ASTM E2214 – Spectral Measurement of Color
HunterLab instruments are designed to support internationally recognized color measurement practices and industry standards.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a spectrophotometer more accurate than a colorimeter?
Both instrument types can provide highly repeatable color measurements. The primary difference is that a spectrophotometer retains complete spectral data, enabling advanced analyses that are not possible with tristimulus measurements alone.
Does a colorimeter measure RGB?
Industrial colorimeters are not RGB sensors. They use three broad-band optical filters designed to approximate the CIE Standard Observer, producing X, Y, and Z tristimulus values from which CIELAB and other color spaces are calculated.
Why is spectral data important?
Spectral data allows color to be recalculated under different illuminants, supports metamerism evaluation, enables color formulation, and preserves the sample's complete optical fingerprint for future analysis.
Do both instruments measure the visible spectrum?
Both instruments are designed to characterize visible color (approximately 400–700 nm). A colorimeter does so using three broad-band filters, while a spectrophotometer measures many individual wavelengths across the visible spectrum. Many spectrophotometers also extend into the UV and NIR for specialized applications.
Can a spectrophotometer perform the same measurements as a colorimeter?
Yes. Because CIELAB, XYZ, and other colorimetric values are calculated from the measured spectrum, a spectrophotometer can perform virtually all routine colorimeter functions while providing additional spectral information for advanced analyses.
Would you like to learn more? Contact us and we'll help you find the best solution for your needs.
For support related questions, submit a support ticket and one of our technical support engineers will contact you as soon as possible!
To learn more about Color and Color Science in industrial QC applications, click here: Fundamentals of Color and Appearance